Re: gcc, specs, and rethinking the sidai -R thing

Responding to Jim Rowan... sorry to be so slow.

> I'd love to see the -R stuff go away as well.  It is a major detractor.
> 
> However, your proposal causes the behavior of ark installed programs
> to be dependant on the configuration of the machine (OS) itself --

[Recap: "my" [vague] proposal was: lose the -R stuff, have some extra
ARK gunk to "manage" the ld.config game (where to find .so files).]

Jim, I agree with your misgivings.  After all, something must've
pushed me into this -R thing in the first place 

I wonder if some sort of hybrid scheme would make sense?  I observe
that not all .so files are created equal...

* things like libgcc_s.so -- every program needs it; carefully managed
  by the GCC lads... Why not just put this in your ld.config...

    /our/.-ark-deploy/gcc--4.0.2/lib
    /our/.-ark-deploy/gcc--3.4.3/lib
    /our/.-ark-deploy/gcc--2.95.3/lib

  ... and declare victory?  If your program picks up the version from
  a different version than what you might've expected, it will almost
  certainly be OK.

* things like libz.so -- very stable interfaces; likely only upgraded
  for security reasons; ubiquitous use; versioning done responsibly.
  Again, having these picked up from a well-controlled ld.config will
  probably be OK.

* things like the Berkeley DB libraries -- you do _not_, on pain of
  death, want a program picking up a version other than the one you
  explicitly intended! -- a horrible horrible death will certainly
  follow.  -R all the way.

Of course, judgement calls are being made in all of that.  So (if you
decided to try to distinguish between those cases), it would a
delicate bit of ARK scripting to keep it all together.

Meanwhile, I wildly support that you should be able to do the kinds of
things you're trying to do ("you don't need anything but a raw box").

(Let me know if I've forgotten something, e.g. from earlier in the
thread.)

Will

-------------------------------------------------------
This SF.net email is sponsored by: Splunk Inc. Do you grep through log files
for problems?  Stop!  Download the new AJAX search engine that makes
searching your log files as easy as surfing the  web.  DOWNLOAD SPLUNK!
http://ads.osdn.com/?ad_id=7637&alloc_id=16865&op=click