Re: Stop Card (was WBF CoC comments solicited)

From: "Herman De Wael" <
>
> I can see a clear difference between a Kaplan question and a Pro one.
>
A big difference.

Evidently Kaplan did not believe that requiring opponents to correct a
deficient explanation constitutes an illegal communication with partner.
There's something to that, but the Laws do say that the TD must be
called when attention is drawn to an irregularity. So it boils down to
whether a deficient explanation is indeed an irregularity. Perhaps that
should be up to the opponents to decide, as it is often a minor and
inadvertent transgression that hardly needs TD attention.

Marv
Marvin L. French
San Diego, California

_______________________________________________
blml mailing list
blml <at> rtflb.org
http://www.amsterdamned.org/mailman/listinfo/blml